Helping managers prepare for difficult workplace conversations
A manager may know that a conversation is needed and still feel unsure how to begin. They might be concerned about upsetting an employee, receiving an unexpected response or making a decision without enough information.
Preparation helps the manager identify the purpose of the discussion, check the facts and think about the support each person may need. It also creates space to consider what they do not yet know.
Identify the issue before choosing the process
An unmet performance standard, an allegation of misconduct and a concern about health or capacity require different considerations. They can overlap, so seek People & Culture advice where the appropriate process is unclear. Avoid deciding what caused a problem before hearing from the employee.
Ask what the meeting needs to establish. An initial discussion might clarify expectations, explore barriers or gather information. If an allegation requires formal assessment or investigation, arrange the appropriate process before treating it as a routine coaching conversation.
Prepare a small set of relevant facts
For a performance discussion, identify the expected standard and the specific work that has raised concern. Check whether the expectation was explained, whether the employee had the necessary resources and what earlier feedback or support was provided.
The Fair Work Ombudsman’s underperformance guide recommends explaining the meeting’s purpose in advance, providing relevant documents and allowing preparation time. It also recommends inviting the employee to bring a support person. Check any applicable workplace process before arranging the meeting.
Practise the opening
Write a short opening that explains the concern without assigning a motive or describing the person’s character. Use the practice session to remove generalisations such as “you always” and to check that the manager can explain the issue in everyday language.
For example: “I’d like to discuss the last two reports. Both were submitted after the agreed deadline, which delayed the team’s review. Can you talk me through what happened?” Rehearse how to pause after the question and allow the employee to answer.
Prepare the opening and the questions. Leave the outcome open until the employee has responded and the relevant information has been considered.
Leave room for information that changes the plan
Listen for information about unclear instructions, workload, training or other circumstances that may affect the next step. Ask questions to understand the response and check your understanding with the employee. If a health concern is raised, consider appropriate support and advice before continuing with a predetermined response.
A manager does not need to resolve every issue during one meeting. Where new information needs checking, explain what will be reviewed and when the conversation will resume. Keep a factual record of the discussion and any outstanding questions.
Make follow-up specific
Where a performance improvement plan is appropriate, clarify the expected work, available support and review arrangements. Check that the employee understands what is required and record the next steps. Allow a reasonable opportunity for improvement that reflects the circumstances.
Managers also benefit from a confidential debrief with their coach or adviser. Consider which questions helped, where assumptions arose and what preparation would help next time. Use those observations to guide further practice.
How The BelRose Group can help
Our coaching and mentoring service supports managers’ development around agreed goals. We also provide tailored training and facilitation, including performance management education and coaching. Contact The BelRose Group to discuss the conversations your managers need support to prepare for.
Email: Support@BelRoseGroup.com.au
Phone: 1300 308 707

